Monday, February 23, 2004
On Dogs as Human Companions
Found via: GeekPress.
The Economist has printed a wonderfully interesting article on canine behavior: Sensitive Souls: How Dogs Became Man's Best Friend.
No one, not even cat owners would (or should) dispute that no other species on the face of the Earth has made the same sympathetic/empathetic [and copacetic :)] connection with humankind as the canine. Yes, I know I am leaning strongly towards anthropomorphizing (sp?) the relationship, but hey, I've known several dogs who were/are friendlier and more interesting characters than a lot of people I know.
Back to the point, the article reports on a study that shows evidence that dogs understand and/or interpret social cues from humans more readily than other species, including chimps, who are thought to be much smarter. The article (not necessarily the author of the study) makes the connection that because of this, man has readily adopted the dog as a live-in companion. Read the article for more info on the study.
I think this is very interesting, and from having lived most of my life with dogs as pets, I have much anecdotal evidence to support the assertion.
My two current canine pals, Judy and Watson, are very good at understanding my cues. Especially Judy, my 13 y.o. female Black Lab, who has grown considerably deaf over the last year. She can no longer interpret verbal commands (unless I yell, which is extremely rare) or even any verbal inflection, but she and I have worked out quite a set of hand cues, and other signals. She knows to come to the door when it is dark outside if I flicker the back door light. She comes when I flex both hands, retreats to the bedroom when I make a "shoo" motion with my left hand, and knows tha clapping means "Good Girl", as her whole body wags.
Watson, my 12 y.o. Yellow Lab will follow hand signals when we are outside playing fetch. If I throw the dummy and he does not see it fly, I can direct him. If it is in tall grass, he'll look to me for a "hint". He certainly understands the words "suppertime", "cookie", "walk", and "Go get a baby", which is his command to find one of his stuffed plush toys for the two of us to play with.
Not exactly the same verbal cues the researcher looked at, but they work for me.
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cba0453ef00d83424fb6353ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference On Dogs as Human Companions:
Comments
My dog, Sam, is completely bonded to me and we are very comfortable together, like old friends should be. We have our routine and she has trained me as much as I have trained her. We watch and listen for each other's signals. Even though my cats are pretty good about doing what I say (at least a couple of them are), Sam and I have a rapport that seems to be on a much higher level of understanding and friendship.
Posted by: Alicia at Feb 24, 2004 2:28:57 PM
I'm sorry, but I can't agree that dogs have a closer empathetic relationship to humans than cats. However, this isn't an either/or situation. I'd say that for some people (myself and my wife, for example), the emotional connection with cats and dogs is about equal.
We love both dogs and cats, and love them both very much. The relationships, however, have different characteristics. Dogs are great if you want an active, extroverted experience, while cats are better for sharing contemplative, introspective experiences.
Of course, that's a big generalization - our Abyssinian cat Macintosh is very dog-like, and we're planning on getting him a dog as a play buddy. We're thinking of a Basenji or a Shiba Inu, since those seem to be the most cat-like dogs.
Posted by: Will Parker at Feb 24, 2004 3:30:47 PM
Your points are taken, Will. I will admit I am strongly baised with respect to dogs over cats. I have always viewed dogs as more personal and interactive with people, and more empathetic. Example: they are now training dogs to help with epileptics as they have found dogs can sense oncoming seizures and warn a patient. Also I do not think we'll ever see a seeing-eye cat. Cats, to me, are much more aloof, more independent, and less connected. Again, this is only my experience.
Posted by: Doc at Feb 24, 2004 8:15:38 PM
Dogs became man's best friend because..........
DOGS ARE HUMAN TOO!!
Posted by: Mike at Mar 16, 2004 4:36:12 AM
